Turlon
Member
Posts: 150
Affiliation: Kashyyyk Sith
|
Post by Turlon on Feb 27, 2015 17:31:54 GMT -8
Fair enough, I'll leave y'all with..."just because one was raised or born with the force..
Aliit ori'shya tal'din
|
|
|
Post by Reyn Skirata on Feb 27, 2015 17:36:24 GMT -8
Being force sensitive is one thing, you can't help how you are born. Being a force user is another thing. The force makes things too easy.
Mishuk gotal'u meshuroke, pako kyore
|
|
Plu Or'dinii
Retired High Councilor
Posts: 159
Affiliation: Mandalorian Clan Or'dinii
Traffic Light: Orange
|
Post by Plu Or'dinii on Feb 27, 2015 21:52:42 GMT -8
IC, Plu believes that the Force is a tool, and that since he was born with it, he should learn how to use it. But he will not actively use it unless he has no other option. For example, if someone were trying to kill his family and the only way to save them was with the Force, then he would resort to Force use. And because he himself is hiding something, he's not going to turn in a fellow Mando for using the Force unless he believes that you are misusing it or are a genuine threat to the vode.
OOC, I largely believe that the Mandos should not allow force users at all, although I'm open to making (a small number of) exceptions. It does tend to make you an overly powerful RP character, but if someone does it and makes it work, I'll roll with it -- not going to tell other people what they can't write. I'd just advise against it and let it go at that.
|
|
Spectre
Member
Posts: 273
Affiliation: The Moon Goddess/ Dha Werda Verda
Traffic Light: Blue
|
Post by Spectre on Feb 28, 2015 9:37:02 GMT -8
All valuable input. Even you Turlon. But you did walk into this one. We could use a little more decorum but being as we are Mando's that would involve a challenge in the battle circle. xD
Reyn is right, but he could be a little nicer. But then again, this is the Mandalorian OOC so enter at your own peril. We have a thing about Aruetiise. Plus, We've had enough Trolls coming on here bossing people around as is. If you haven't read.
Plu, I agree wholeheartedly with IC and OOC sentiments and share them. The biggest concern(and a very valid one) is making them overly and unfairly powerful. Reyn has very strong points being as he was here when there was rampant PGing from the FB days. I read the archives when the original 1.5 was around.
As Plu said I only want to make a small number of exceptions in a controlled environment. Like Corr but less powerful. (Powers like Speed, Tutaminis, and Body that can be reflexive) I want to lift the taboo, but no Force use allowed on Manda'yaim. None. That should make some people feel a little better about the lift of the taboo. (Keyword should but I don't think it will xD)
|
|
|
Post by Reyn Skirata on Feb 28, 2015 9:52:32 GMT -8
And what I'm saying is, don't expect anyone to be happy about it, or to trust them. You are free to do whatever you want, but you have to accept that people will not like it. I am not sure if Reyn ever knew Plu was a force user, i don't think so. I can't tell you what to do and what to play, your RP is your own, all I can say is what i've seen come from this, and how traditionalists will view you.
|
|
Spectre
Member
Posts: 273
Affiliation: The Moon Goddess/ Dha Werda Verda
Traffic Light: Blue
|
Post by Spectre on Feb 28, 2015 10:24:14 GMT -8
I don't expect anyone to like it. It wouldn't be fair. There will always be traditionalists and progressives. Anyone who's ever been in the military knows about unpopular orders and being the one who has to enforce them. This I know. A Colonel on base one year did some inspections on our base and didn't like what he saw, so he cancelled Christmas leave and ordered training exercises. I expect opposition but I know change won't happen over night. I have to earn trust through example. I know you aren't telling what to play and how, I see that you are giving adequate heads up. And I thank you for that. Sincerely. It's just going to happen slowly over time. That's all. I welcome your opinion because it's exactly what I will have to face and overcome. Or not overcome. Only time will tell.
|
|
Plu Or'dinii
Retired High Councilor
Posts: 159
Affiliation: Mandalorian Clan Or'dinii
Traffic Light: Orange
|
Post by Plu Or'dinii on Feb 28, 2015 12:01:28 GMT -8
I don't think Reyn ever knew IC. It wasn't as much of a secret in the old days as it is now, but I didn't exactly advertise it, either. Plu wanted to fit in, in spite of his origins.
If anyone dug deeply enough into his past and who he was and what he did as a young man (on 1.0), then they might realize the truth. But that was something like 30 years ago IC time.
It's all a moot point anyway because I'm pretty sure Plu won't be using the force again in open RP.
|
|
|
Post by Jaccien Ordo on Mar 1, 2015 22:32:17 GMT -8
I think we all need to meet at the Oyu'baat, drink tihaar, and fight each other until our characters all need medical attention. Like real Mandalorians.
Nothing gets solved but at least we got a few stiff drinks and some training in...
|
|
Corr
Member
You can lead a fool to knowledge but you can't make him think.
Posts: 940
Affiliation: Clan Vhett
Traffic Light: Orange
|
Post by Corr on Mar 2, 2015 16:47:38 GMT -8
Err... Thanks Dan. I am utterly devastated by your comments. I will now be rethinking Corr's entire life and questioning every post I've ever made. I can agree with the argument that a Mandalorian using the Force could be considered a valuable asset and could even argue Dan's statement that not all Mandalorians using force powers are powergaming munchkins. I could also refer to the fact that it is not unheard of in canon and is accepted in some circles. There will always be writers here that lean to one way and some to the other much the same was that the Mando's themselves leaned one way or the other. It is, like a lot of things, a matter of opinion. The problem as I always looked at it is that Force using Mando's are supposed to be rare to the point of endangered. In fact, I know of only two in canon. Having Mandalorian leaders and hero's leaping around throwing TK everywhere gives the wrong image. I would also argue that even if a Mando were Force Sensitive attributing similar abilities to Jedi and Sith is utter nonsense. They would possess only the most basic of abilities at best and would likely never develop any powers beyond a vague sense of things. It takes years of training to gain such attributes, years which a Mandalorian spends his/her time training in their own cultural inclinations. A Force sensitive Mando would have to train under a Jedi/Sith/Fallanassi or whatever to progress and, lets be honest, such cults would be mad to train a Mandalorian. I wrote a Force Sensitive character. Like Pul it was before I knew better and in a time when if you didn't have Force powers you may as well bend over and get rogered by every other writer out there. I got creative with the back story and had sufficient interactions with IC force users to explain the ability to perform certain skills but EVEN THEN I always wrote the power as 1) half formed and unpredictable and 2) That he was ashamed of, and reluctant to use them. That made up for it in later years but as still a stretch by my reckoning. Anyway. That's my ramble. You can, of course, write your characters as you see fit. That is both the beauty and curse of this site. Edit: I missed two pages that I didn't realise were there though little of the above has changed. Again, I am a bad example to state Spectre. As much as I loved writing a Mando and had some small success as such, I was always a Jedi at heart. A Yavin Jedi at that, which seems rather frowned upon these days... I came across to the Mando's and based everything I wrote on characters like Reyn and Cassus Fett. Now you may look on the face of things and think that these two role models (for want of a better term) are completely different (One being Force sensitive and one not) but that is not the case at all. By then James was writing Cassus much as I have written Corr the last couple of years. Keeping the Force sensitivity on the down low. He never went as far as what I did with Corr in that I had Corr ashamed of his Force sensitivity, but he definitely shunned it towards the end. I wrote Corr at the end as manifesting the spirit of Kad, or having Kad guide his steps, in an effort to put any such force sensitivity as a divine power much like that of a Paladin. It was quite a bit of fun doing so. Anyway, I digress. Point is that I always based my Mando compass on Cassus and Reyn and I'd advise being guided by such in this. Giving the green light, in whatever aspect, to force use among Mando's is not going to endear you to 90% of Mandalorians IC (going by canon ) unless it is for such a small minority that would be pretty much indistinguishable from your average warrior anyway. (see above) Irrelevant of opinion I truly believe these days that unless you have a backstory where your character was raised by Jedi/Sith/whatever and then adopted the Mandalorian way (Highly unlikely though not impossible) or was raised as a Mando and then trained with Jedi/Sith (again....) then there is literally no point in mentioning being, or in fact actually being, force sensitive apart from to say that your man can be "Lucky" every now and then. Its just not worth it. One more edit: While I commend Dan on any victories against Force users in the past, and have done the same myself at times, nevertheless a trained Force User against a trained non-force user will win near every time unless there is a massive advantage in terms of tech, martial ability, or something to the non-force. Sorry but that's just the way it is. I get that if one trained as a warrior all his life then he maybe has a slight advantage but to have someone of an order like the Jedi/Sith, who are so obviously trained in combat, manifesting supernatural powers... game over man. Force speed and precog alone are enough.
|
|
|
Post by The Admiralty OOC on Mar 3, 2015 10:13:23 GMT -8
The problem with that is that all mandalorian warriors in the modern GFFA are spec ops troopers. in canon there's something like 6 million mandos in the galaxy, the huge sweeping armies of the crusaders and neo-crusaders are long gone. This is another fight i've had to have. 1000 mandalorian warriors is a massive commitment of resources in the present GFFA. That's just how things work these days. Unless you decide to count 'Clan' D'Ordinii, which is several hundred million strong & growing IC. Then again we are making heavy use of 'cloning' (more like mass produced test tube babies than true cloning, but still) & is more like an Imperial/Mando hybrid than the traditional Mando nomadic culture/clan style. Which means while the clan follows the reso'nare they are seen by many if not most mandos as outsiders & the outsiders as mandos. Which is all kinds of fun to RP (one of the main reasons I do it that way). The clan is basically what I came up with when I asked myself "What would happen if the mandos ever grew large enough & remained close-knit enough to form a more formalized command & social structure?" As for the force/no-force side of it. IC: Officially D'Ordinii doesn't care, but has extremely few (double digits tops) force users. Unofficially open force use is frowned on, but the clan has a special brigade of troops that are heavily trained in force use (mainly focusing on counter-force operations & anti-assassination roles), & even then they are kept secret enough that while there are a few uncredited rumours about them being forcies, there is no proof. Of course for someone to even get to the point where they have to step in means they have already passed massive amounts of more traditional countermeasures (& the admiral is paranoid enough that he is willing to use every tool he can get). OOC: If your character started as a forcie & converted I see nothing wrong with having/using the force. Keeping in mind that over the years Mando force users have shifted back & forth between "He's a cool guy" & "Burn the Witch". Since this has happened several times within the lifetime of most of the longer-lived mandos (say a hundred years or so) Any force using mando, regardless of origin & power level would be more likely to keep quiet about their powers or only share the info with a few close friends/lovers. Mainly as the ones that are open about it during the 'cool' periods tend to be the first ones targeted during the 'witch' periods. As for character born/raised mando that 'discover' their ability to use the force, they would likely thing long & hard about whether it is even worth the risk to learn how to use the skill as many would have likely seen a 'forcie hunt' first hand. especially with the last anti-force crusade so fresh in mind. Edit Note: Careful readers will note that I said nothing about being PG or GM or overpowered or anything like that. Personally I don't really care how powerful or weak a character is as long as they are well done & believable. Is a character with force powers or mando training powerful? yes. Is a character with force powers & mando training powerful? debatable as both of those things generally require a lifetime of focus by themselves. To use the D&D/Pathfinder examples from above: A 20th level fighter is a beast in close combat. A 20th level Wizard/Sorcerer/etc (though one could argue that forcies are already more like Cleric/Monk hybrids, but that would make this note much longer & more complicated) will tear you apart with their mind. A 10th level fighter/10th level W/S/E is capable at either close range or with mental stuff, but will nearly always lose in a straight up fight with one of the others (The fighter will kick their rear & the mage will kill them from a range). Their strong point isn't being better or even as good as either class, but being able to shift from one style to another (having enough raw power to get up in the mage's face & having enough magic to hit the fighter from range).
|
|
Corr
Member
You can lead a fool to knowledge but you can't make him think.
Posts: 940
Affiliation: Clan Vhett
Traffic Light: Orange
|
Post by Corr on Mar 3, 2015 13:06:58 GMT -8
Clone Mando's would likely be seen as abominations more than outsiders... At least to quite a few Mando's I know.
|
|
Cuyan Skirata
The Vegemite Enclave
Posts: 109
Affiliation: Kara'yaim
|
Post by Cuyan Skirata on Mar 4, 2015 8:01:20 GMT -8
So anyway, how should we move forward?
|
|
Spectre
Member
Posts: 273
Affiliation: The Moon Goddess/ Dha Werda Verda
Traffic Light: Blue
|
Post by Spectre on Mar 4, 2015 11:03:00 GMT -8
It seems to me, (and I may or may not be correct in this assessment) that an OOC consensus is that no one has a problem if people have powers that are reflexive. I wouldn't want to assume anything like having them tossing out TK like pro's. Seeing as we would cross the line of becoming actually Jedi and losing our identity that makes us what we are. So I agree with the apprehensions of those who dissent in their opinion. A basic to moderate understanding is all I am trying to accomplish to learn control.
Reyn: Believe this or not, but the reason I made Spectre a Skirata is because of you and what you have done. At some point I would like to find Reyn and his wife's burial site and return them both back to Kyrimorut. I think I saw you mention them both being somewhere else?
Corr: I know you got your template from Cassus. Though it wasn't my place to say it. Spectre's Force dichotomy is homage to you both. Plotwise he believes he was saved by the Moon Goddess of Pantora and in turn believes he got these reflexive powers from her, so not very far off from what Corr believes. Whereas, where Corr was going with his Character before the Yavin debacle fell apart is totally your choice, I would like to see you and Sid come back to some capacity to continue and finish that idea. Seeing as I am going to do my best to lift the taboo. Note the Words: to do my best.
Admy: The Clone issue will be addressed the same as the taboo. Clan Discretion. Although, IC character prejudices will still remain along with the lifting of the taboo I expect.
Now for people and their IC views, I don't expect them to change overnight, if at all. It will make for some interesting RP nonetheless. Force use will be banned and having someone who is sensitive to enforce it makes sense. Spectre is just attempting to make a place safe for his daughter Meony without being overtly reviled for what she is. Which is the basis of why I am doing this. It's all about family.
Jaccien: We'll have plenty of time to do that once we get everyone back to the 'baat.
Cuy: Our direction is anti-slavery. So we will get to that soon.
I chatted with Duke/Atia/Nan about the story and he's on board. Spectre found out about Juvex Import/Exports through the Draykon Crew and intend to free them once delivered. Thing is posting with the Crew is slow and there is no telling how long this will take. There will probably be more than what is there and will tip off Spectre about the whole slavery issue that will need to be addressed and call out to the Aliit'alors for a meeting. Since Jaccien and Crew are trying to liberate Kashyyyk, I feel we will be heading there to lead a campaign as well. Which could potentially lead to a combination of Juvex and Kashyyyk and make a decent campaign for us.
|
|
Corr
Member
You can lead a fool to knowledge but you can't make him think.
Posts: 940
Affiliation: Clan Vhett
Traffic Light: Orange
|
Post by Corr on Mar 4, 2015 18:05:11 GMT -8
I never really went away, ner vod, and if you look hard enough you'll see I'm still kicking around the galaxy in some capacity or another. I personally believe too much is being made of this Force Sensitivity issue. If people want to write a Force Sensitive Mando then it is up to them in my opinion. I am just all for the "sticking with canon" fact that the vast majority of Mando's would shun such a thing. If one were to write a Force Sensitive Mando then they should be aware of the stipulations and write accordingly. Alas that is not always the case. Be that as it may I think that there are more important factors to consider in light of any wish to rebuild the Mandalorian Empire to a force rivalling that it once was. Here is where my own opinion may differ vastly that some other. I am of the opinion that the Mandalorian Empire should not be reformed in any way shape or form resembling what it was. I think it would serve us best from and IC point of view as well as an OOC one to go back to the Clan-based structure that we often see the Mando's adopting in times of unrest. Each clan looking after their own with only lip service paid to the Mand'alor. Now I know that you may not like this track, Spectre, and may well wish to lead the vode to glory and whatnot, a stance which I understand and respect. I just believe the ME as we knew it is redundant at this time. From an OOC perspective I think Mando writers would gain a lot more from working in groups with other non-Mando writers in order to get themselves bountiful RP AND to spread Mando activity around the galaxy and into other group-areas. That would at once promote Mando RP and stimulate other RP AND possibly encourage others to write a Mando character. Spectre would still be Mand'alor and could still dictate some policy, perhaps even brokering trade, assembling and leading Mando units, interacting with other leaders of other user groups, or just cracking on doing his own thing. Boba did such a thing for years after all. My reasoning for this stance is that with as little activity on the site as I've seen for a long time I just don't think it's viable to maintain a large usergroup in todays writing environment. I have been poking around the last few days and the smaller writing groups seem to be the ones weathering the storm. Aside from the Jedi there is little in the way of any faction or power prevalent on the site these days and perhaps such adaptation is the key to survival. I am not saying close the user group or veer off in a completely different direction. Just do what works. Open the major worlds to trade (IC narrative as well as actual RP) and promote small group RP there. Get every one of these worlds (I'm talking about the Clan Capitals like Mandalore, Concord Dawn etc) on the same page with regards to what is happening with the Mando culture. For example I am operating on the basis that the Mando campaign against the Jedi was a major fail of some sort, hence the fact that we are not camped at the gates of the Core with a battering ram made out of Jedi skulls. I understand that some may have tried to wipe that whole story arc from their memories and if so then that is the kind of thing we should be discussing. Find some middle ground where our characters can interact better with what is happening AND interact with the greater galaxy as a whole. We all know fellow writers in other factions, hell some of us write other characters in other faction. Should be easy to get a feel of what's compatible. To sum up I feel that these are the things that need to be looked at in order to rebuild the Mando writing group as a coherent force on this site. I may be wrong. Other may have differing opinions. In light of such questions, though, I feel the discussion on the Force is really a small thing and one that is unlikely to get adequately solved any time soon. Lets sit down and address issues that we can vigorously attack and see what we can mash together. xxx
|
|
Cathaoir Ordo
Member
Posts: 346
Affiliation: Mandalorian Clan Ordo
Traffic Light: Green
|
Post by Cathaoir Ordo on Mar 4, 2015 19:22:56 GMT -8
Well been away for a few months now; you know how life happens. Definitely don't expect to see the Mandos of old back to showing here and there (ie Corr, Reyn, Plu, etc). Happy to see you guys back. Anyways, on a more serious note, I'd like to relate back to the topic at hand.
I seem to recall that not long before life dragged me away from here, we were still on much of the same topic, being a Force Sensitive/User or equivalent. What I explained back then is my thoughts and relating to canon and the Resol'nare is better explained in the comments about from both Corr and Reyn. Where I wasn't able to really put what I really wanted to say into words, they have been about to do extraordinarily well if I do say so myself.
Main points in which they hit that i would like to add to are:
Force As Corr was saying, "...Force using Mando's are supposed to be rare to the point of endangered. In fact, I know of only two in canon. Having Mandalorian leaders and hero's leaping around throwing TK everywhere gives the wrong image." That in my own opinion is the complete truth regarding that issue. Yes, I may write Cath as someone who hates and utterly despises everything about the Force, but that is not my OOC stance on the issue; it's just how I developed him as a character, so please don't try and relate me and my stance to that. Basically, the Force, both Sensitivity and Usage was few and far between, and even that in some instances is an understatement.
For anyone to say the have a Mandalorian with mastery in the Force in any way is shenanigans to me and would require evident proof in writing that it would even be remotely possible for their character to have learned abilities to that level. I have yet to come across any example in canon to back up why any Mandalorian would be a Master in using the force and until then I will not be able to accept any case of it without legitimate proof of years of training and then as to why/how they either became a part of the Mandalorian Culture and/or was not not cast from it when they would have left for years to train under someone who had the adequate knowledge and skill to train someone
Mandalorian Empire It's hard for me to write this as an actual topic header as there should really be no such thing. Mandalorians were loosely knit together clans that ran themselves in a manner of speaking. The Mand'alor sat in no almighty throne nor was any kind of Emperor, Dictator, King, etc. When the time came and the Mand'alor called on the clans, more or less their reputation and the "strongest" among the culture should have been enough to rally the clans to a cause. And take note that I used the word "rally" and not "order." Mand'alor holds no immediate jurisdiction over any individual clan if recall right.
Also, to tag on, I believe that the "Mandalorian Empire" usergroup was initially created as a means to be able to distribute infomation to the Mandalorians as a whole. A distro group in a manner of speaking.
--------------
So I believe thats about all I wanted to touch on besides letting you all know I haven't left yet, only had life get in the way for a bit. But if there's anything I think of I'll make sure to tage it on in later posts
|
|
Spectre
Member
Posts: 273
Affiliation: The Moon Goddess/ Dha Werda Verda
Traffic Light: Blue
|
Post by Spectre on Mar 5, 2015 11:16:49 GMT -8
Corr: I know you keep your ever watchful eye on us. I was just referring to returning to an active IC status. You posted once a while back and that was it. As for the status of the Crusade. It's over. Our new direction is going to reflect that. The Clan leaders are going to have free reign (not the actual Reyn xD) to do as they wish. My hope is to get some anti-slavery like-minded Vode to move against Juvex Import/Exports and (attempt) to liberate Kashyyyk. Since Clan leaders have the say in this, it's up to them to decide if they want to lend support. As for commerce, Mandalmines needs to be repaired and Mandalmotors brought back to the forefront. Start getting some action over here. Once the slaves on Kessel are freed, I am going to suggest that they be brought here by the Draykon Crew to have to chance at avenging themselves. Bringing some RP home.
Cath: Welcome back and Congrats on winning Mando of the year! I agree whole-heartedly with returning control over to the Aliit'alors. As a matter of fact I have stated that several times. I agree we aren't an Empire. So with that being said we need Clan user groups. I just need to find some more Skirata to do this. xD As for someone leaving to be Jedi and coming back? You forgot about Cassus. Cassus became Mand'alor, resigned (I think?), went to the Jedi, became a knight and Master (Again I think.) left the Jedi and came back to be Mand'alor a second time. (Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong Andi.)
Last bit on the taboo, my aim is to present a unified front. While on planet any Mando can act as they want but I feel they shouldn't show said feelings to aruetiise about their Vode. No Force use is tolerated on Manda'yaim and having those who can sense it and enforce the rules against those who do violate the laws.
As for those who are Force-sensitive, I was thinking of having a group named the Dha Werda Verda(Shadow Warriors). Like a Dirty Half-Dozen. xD Keep it secret and place sleeper cells to fight against Force-users as a last ditch effort to fight them off and win. But those are just OOC ideas.
|
|
|
Post by Jaccien Ordo on Mar 5, 2015 13:55:37 GMT -8
Just to be clear there are technically no Wookiee slaves on Kashyyyk. I'm down to have more Mandos on Kashyyyk to help me out but that is something we would have to talk to Turlon about.
|
|
Corr
Member
You can lead a fool to knowledge but you can't make him think.
Posts: 940
Affiliation: Clan Vhett
Traffic Light: Orange
|
Post by Corr on Mar 5, 2015 16:40:21 GMT -8
Cayne Tristan is currently in command of Clan Vhett interest. Any such involvement of Concord Dawn in such things as anti-slavery operations would have to go through him IC.
|
|
|
Post by D. Villain on Mar 7, 2015 16:15:59 GMT -8
Hey everyone, looking to start up this new character of mine as a Mando, and would be interested in joining with you guys.
|
|
Atia
Member
Posts: 1,232
Affiliation: Nightsisters of Dathomir
|
Post by Atia on Mar 8, 2015 5:15:41 GMT -8
I am waiting for you good peeps to show up on my doorstep, just give me a headsup.
|
|