Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 23, 2016 18:23:54 GMT -8
The Jedi Code So, as my more eloquent colleague put it here, there is a fairly glaring flaw in the current Jedi Order. In Canon, the Jedi Order has followed a number of different principles, or codes. The Jedi Order under Yoda had very strict ideas on what it was to be a Jedi, and whether one was allowed attachments and at what age a Padawan could be taken on at. The New Jedi Order under Luke was a lot more loose with these ideals. In both instances, one could say that these orders were merely adopting policies necessary for the climates they existed in. JvS has seen more than it's fair share of Jedi Order's, with some orders leaning more towards the old Jedi Order and others leaning more towards the new Jedi Order. These differences seemed to divide groups, whilst others were merely about the location and positioning of a Temple. As time has gone by, however, the various Orders finally came together to form one united Jedi Order. And that is where we are today, a united Jedi Order, that in some respects, isn't truly so united. This is because in all the work that was done to unite the orders, we've never really taken a moment to take a look at what it means to be a Jedi on JvS. What it is that the Jedi Order stands for, what it believes in, whether we're heavy handed or provide a fair amount of autonomy. We have such a mix of Jedi and views from the amalgamations of the various Order's, with no one clear unifying Code. Many of us have just made assumptions about how things are run, and how we all act. Differing opinions and wanting different freedoms and views is what created such division within the number of Order's to begin with. Which isn't to say it is a bad thing. But as we see such a storyline beginning anew now, it really brings to the forefront the idea that we have yet to figure out who we are as a whole. So, as Aerandir mentioned in the Jedi Order thread, we'd like to get an open discussion on this matter with our various Jedi writer's. We want to know what your character thinks it means to be a Jedi, how they think the Order operates or should operate. But also what you, as a writer, thinks it means to be a Jedi, etc. I say this, as your characters views can sometimes be at odds with what you as a writer thinks. By accumulating these ideas and views, we can hash out a combined Code so that we can have a very universal view of what the Jedi are. Obviously there is going to have to be some compromise and at times, ideas that conflict with each other. To that end, I just ask that everyone remains respectful, so that we can work together. With all that out of the way, I open the floor...
|
|
The Shepherd
Member
Posts: 269
Affiliation: Yavin IV Praxeum
Traffic Light: Orange
|
Post by The Shepherd on Oct 23, 2016 18:48:49 GMT -8
I'll go ahead and open the line of discussion.
As far as I'm concerned as a writer, a Jedi should be merciful, but with the capacity to be merciless if need be. A Jedi should be willing to help those in need, but also able to see the bigger picture. And a Jedi should be able to see all points of view in that aforementioned bigger picture - and truly understand them - but also be able to choose a path and stick with it when the time comes. But above all else, a Jedi should follow the Jedi Code and stick to it above all else, no matter what the universe throws their way. To break from the code is to divorce oneself from the Jedi Order altogether; either because they've cast aside their entire raising in the case of the old orders, or because they've cast aside everything else to become a Jedi. It's a monastic order of knights dedicated to keeping the peace across the galaxy. It's not a day job. And in the past, people have claimed to be a Jedi while chasing tail, lashing out in anger, swearing to end a family line, the works.
As far as the shepherd is concerned, the Jedi of JvS have been entirely too forgiving of the various Dark Side factions across the galaxy. Letting the known Sith stronghold of Kashyyyk go unopposed? Sitting around on Yavin babying repeat-offender darksiders? Running a daycare in a fungus jungle? Tolerance of orders that claimed to govern? As the years went on and Rutil fought the good fight, he grew increasingly impatient with anything that didn't somehow forward the mission of the Jedi Order. Further still, given the horrors the dark side visits upon the weak of the galaxy and the inaction of the Jedi, Rutil's gone full Spanish Inquisition; even dabbling or experimenting with darkness carries a death sentence at this stage in his life. Rutil is definitely an exception from the norm (and it helps, no doubt, that he's certifiably insane by this point) and he certainly takes the Jedi Code to its most violent extreme, but he still follows it. And from his uber-conservative standpoint, that still makes him more deserving of the title than many.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 23, 2016 20:58:54 GMT -8
Greetings all, I am Dante Deveaux, ambassador to The Order of Vandelhelm. We have received much inquiry and curiosity as to our organization and its purpose. From questions courtesy of Aerandir Calmcacil on behalf of the current Order, to private messages, to long chat discussions. We have stayed deliberately silent, however, and this has been by purposeful design. We wanted to be sure of our resolve, of both purpose and commitment to our new Order, before announcing ourselves publicly. The Order of Vandelhelm, in the simplest of terms, is seeking to reconnect with what it means to be a Jedi. We wish to do this, because, as time has gone by here on the site, the very definition of what it means to be "Jedi" has fluctuated, shifted, and changed rapidly. This is to be expected, of course, with a site of so many people, with so many differing views. However. The current iteration of what it means to be a Jedi - large armies, fleets, vast resources unbecoming for any one Jedi, is distasteful to us. We are keepers of the peace - not soldiers. This slight could have been looked over, perhaps, if such resources had been put to actual use; but, as The Shepherd said before us - Kashyyyk remains a Sith world, despite vast resources to take it. And, in reference to the Sith, their own numbers and factions have grown wildly out of proportion to Jedi forces, with Jedi being lax in actively being Jedi, and putting a stop to letting such corruption grow in their backyard. This, combined with baby sitting repeated dark-side offenders, not to mention numerous distortions ad infinitum of what the Jedi Code even means - all add up to, in our humble opinion, the fact that Jedi have stopped being Jedi at a fundamental level. Assigning blame, concocting defenses, figuring our who is right, who is wrong, who did what, who said what when: this is all entirely beside the point. The Order of Vandelhelm seeks to remove ourselves to one of the most remote planets in our galaxy, Vandelhelm, where we can strive to become true Jedi again. Vandelhelm is envisioned by our Order as a transformative place, a safe place; a place where a character can go, and undergo metamorphosis into a clearer and more well defined version of what it means to be a Jedi. I myself, a Gray Jedi for many years, owner of many possessions, credits, and armies; even now I myself undergo that transformation, asking myself IRL, as well as IC, "What does it mean to be truly a Jedi?" And then undertaking that transformation. More so, though, we envision Vandelhelm as a place where we do not have to answer the Jedi Order leadership at large, or even the scrutinizing eyes of others and their opinions of what a Jedi, and their version of the Code means. We by no means intend any offense or vengefulness. We wish to keep an amicable relation with the Jedi Order, and other factions on the site. However, we deliberately fashioned this Order so that we would be held accountable to ourselves, and only ourselves. We want, in a word - a clean start. Our Order grows daily, and we have continued interest. We are, at this time, taking members on a case by case basis. We are not an Order you join simply for a few stories, just to leave a few days later. We are an Order you join if you want true development, insight, and growth into moving not only your character, but the site as a whole to a purer Jedi orientation. You will only be answerable to yourself, as well as your peers - and vice versa. There will be no further statements or discussion on the subject within this thread. We go in peace, and ask you let us do so. All queries and interest to our Order should be directed through PM to myself, Gene Kenobi, or Amlu Eerkerk. Thank you my friends. - Dante Deveaux, Ambassador to The Order of Vandelhelm
|
|
Aerandir Calmcacil
The Jedi Order
Posts: 1,731
Affiliation: The Jedi Order
Traffic Light: Green
|
Post by Aerandir Calmcacil on Oct 23, 2016 21:03:04 GMT -8
To be honest, a lot of how I feel about the Jedi Order overlaps with Aerandir's views. It's best to start with his views, as they're the most applicable and relevant to the Jedi Order of JvS.
And to be honest, he's kind of a radical in many ways. Servant of the light? Yes. But by the Jedi's rules? Not exactly. His early training was influenced by the teachings of a Jedi who survived Order 66, blaming the stringent regulations of the Jedi for their downfall. Through several life experiences, she reinterpreted many tenets up until her death, writing them down and passing them on. Someday I'll write this story out in its entirety. But to him, a Jedi is one who serves the light and is meant to protect, this much is true. However, he doesn't necessarily believe that feelings like fear and anger are inherently evil; rather, allowing yourself to be controlled by them is what will hinder you. Hell, righteous anger can be justifiable in his eyes, so long as one is still in control.
As far as battle and politics go, there's nothing wrong with a little strategizing or advising, but typically speaking those duties should fall to those whose jobs it is unless it's absolutely necessary to take over, at least until such a time as they can replace themselves with someone qualified for the job. Mainly, this applies to politics and leadership, apart from within the the Jedi Order itself of course. Basically, the Jedi will govern themselves and be the magical law enforcement, serving when called upon or when their services are offered. On the battlefield, there'd be a little more leniency, seeing as they can see and do things the non-Force generals and commanders cannot. They should work together to achieve their ends, playing off each other's strengths and weaknesses. Doesn't mean they can't be present at the strategy meetings or even take command, however.
And honestly? He's somewhat lax in many ways. Laid-back attitude, recognizing there's a time and place for being serious, but also that levity when appropriate can go a long way. Ease the tension when it's too thick, that kind of thing. Banter even, but only with those who accept it. Obviously never lose focus, but no need to be a stiff all the time either. If people want to take everything seriously, fair. If they don't, also fair, so long as it's not in a capacity that endangers themselves or others. He doesn't believe in controlling anyone, unless they are actually causing problems. At the end of the day, one's focus and dedication is what matters, not their attitude. Well, attitude matters, but you know what I'm saying.
That's pretty much what I believe as well. There's a need to be sure of one's self and their dedication, but the most important aspect is their devotion to justice and the light.
"An object cannot make you good or evil. The temptation of power, forbidden knowledge, even the desire to do good can lead some down that path. But only you can change yourself." - The Bendu.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 24, 2016 0:36:52 GMT -8
Well, I have to admit, there is a lot of valid points both from an IC and OOC perspective from both Shepherd and Dante. There is some disconnect between what a Jedi is/should be and how a lot of people have been portraying them both before and after the unification efforts. I mean, we took several Orders with differing ideologies and combined them together. It was undoubtedly going to come to a point where we needed to do some course correcting, and that moment is right now. The fact it has taken so long to actually get around to this topic isn't perhaps desirable, but considering the time and effort it took to unite the factions, then realise we lacked the man power to maintain 6 different enclaves, and decide which one's we were going to try hold and where to base ourselves from. Well, it's probably about on schedule for this kind of thing to happen. To that end, I really do hope we can all work together as a community of writer's to fix this. The whole purpose of this discussion, is essentially very much in line with what you guys are trying to achieve. The Order needs some reform, and if we work together, we can achieve that. I certainly agree that Jedi shouldn't have massive fleets, armies and resources at their personal command. Although, admittedly, I can't say I've seen a Jedi with these kinds of resources under their personal ownership since before the Republic was disbanded. But either way, I certainly agree that no single Jedi should have control of such things. The Order as a whole? sure, if these resources are provided by a government/group to aide in completing some short term mission. In terms of Kashyyyk, that is no longer a Sith world, and the resources committed to it are back in appropriate hands. Yeah, the fact it remained that way so long sucks, but then, no one wanted to try deal with the OOC fallout from that. And yeah, there has been a number of places avoided because the writer's who we should have gone after, weren't always amicable to such things, or were not approached in an amicable way. It's just a part of how JvS was. Is it still that way? I don't believe as much, but obviously you will always come across writers who have darksiders that they don't necessarily want their characters dying just yet. I can't say I know exactly what you mean as far as the infinite distortions of the Jedi Code go. Though, admittedly, even canon had no one clear interpretation of it. But even I admit, we could do with a good reminder of what the Jedi Code in its most fundamental form is: with some further expounding with this: Those are certainly qualities I have tried to ensure Rawkill follows, and ones he has tried to ensure are upheld by others. Rawkill and Rutil were certainly at some odds over such points IC. Which admittedly, was a rather fun thing to write. There are a lot of tenets to which Rawkill adheres, with the exception of those that specifically related to the time of the Republic (taking more than one padawan, regardless of age. And enforced celibacy). In most respects, I certainly agree with Shephard's assessment of what it means to be a Jedi from an OOC standpoint. Follow the core tenets of the code. Remember that you are a Jedi first and foremost. Your duty is to the Order. I certainly think we are moving along the right path, but there are still a number of Jedi IC that need some coaxing back upon that path. After all, it wasn't enough to call yourself a Jedi in canon. You had to abide by the teachings, and practice what was preached. If you look at the Shaolin Monks, for which I think are a good comparison to the Jedi Order in some respects, they still have to practice their beliefs. Something I feel some Jedi have forgotten to do IC and tend more towards just calling themselves Jedi. Rawkill certainly echoes many of these sentiments. As I said, he more leans towards the new Jedi Order's Code. He understands that the Jedi aren't as prosperous as they once were. He also knows the value of knowledge, as appropriate for his position upon the Council of First Knowledge. He certainly wouldn't kill someone that was unarmed. He recognises that there is things that need to change about the Order, mostly because he has seen how the Order has operated in the past, and compares some of it with the way a lot of Jedi act now. there was some more, I think, but my train of thought has been derailed, so... just leaving it at this for now.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 25, 2016 10:34:37 GMT -8
I don't think we need to reinvent the wheel where the Jedi Code is concerned; which is not at all said to dissuade or discourage the discussion so much as to serve as a starting point for my answer to the question posed. My character and I both view the original Code, along with the amendment/ revision Rawkill quoted in his post above as the essential tenets or essence of what it means to be a Jedi, and while I can see where we need to, from an OOC standpoint, come to some consensus as to what exactly those things mean or should look like here on JvS, I think they could serve perfectly well as the IC Code the Jedi Order agrees upon.
For my character, a Jedi is above all else an agent and servant of the Light Side of the Force that follows the Jedi Code. What form that service takes can range from serving as an instructor to the next generation of Jedi, being a healer or diplomat, to being a warrior that defends the weak or seeks out and confronts those that oppose the Light Side and/ or those that serve the Dark Side. My character definitely believes that to be a Jedi requires an absolute commitment, in that one has to sacrifice those things (be it possessions, outside commitments, or personal attachments) which she feels would by their nature take time, energy of one kind or another, and effort away from what one owes to their duties as a Jedi. That being said, my character has enough humility to understand that some are able to maintain families or relationships without allowing those to detract from their duties. My character would agree that Jedi should not hold political offices or command armies and fleets, though she would understand that a Jedi's duty might require that they advise or protect those that hold political offices, or fight alongside armies and fleets when required. As far as possessions are concerned, my character is definitely of the "my robes and my lightsaber are all that I can call my own" mold.
While my character believes that following the Jedi Code means always striving to find a non-violent resolution to conflict, she also believes that a Jedi must possess the resolve to take action when diplomacy or compromise fail or are not possible; a lightsaber is not only a symbol of a Jedi's commitment, but a weapon meant to be used when needed.
As a writer, I agree with my character's beliefs for the most part. I think, so far as writing collaborative fiction is concerned, the biggest challenge is that actively confronting the bad guy is not as easy as it sounds when the bad guy has a writer behind them that is every bit as invested in their character and their character's story as the Jedi's writer; and that typically results in conflicts in agendas where connecting stories are concerned, since (unlike in a novel or movie) there is not often an agreed upon ending point that is being worked towards but two players trying to "win".
|
|
Mike Frantz
Member
That Guy
Posts: 721
Affiliation: The Jedi Order
|
Post by Mike Frantz on Oct 25, 2016 16:02:21 GMT -8
So I'm a bit out of date on everything, but I randomly saw this and decided to add my two or three cents.
Firstly while we should have some collective idea of what the term "jedi" means, I don't know if we should start denying people the right to call themselves Jedi if they don't conform to our opinions of what that means. Although I suppose anyone is entitled to call themselves whatever they want *Declares himself kind of the booze just for kicks* and this would be more of "what the official jedi order considers its members to be" sort of thing. That being said as a writer I agree that a Jedi should definitely be "jedi first" and be fully committed to the order and what it stands for, not a "casual membership" sort of thing. It should also stand for rightness and light and all the fluffy bunny feelings possible... but within reason. We can't just go charging into sith controlled planets that we can't hope to "Liberate" just because it's the right thing to do, we've got to be reasonable about our capabilities both IC and OOC, we've got to respect what the bad guy writers have in mind as well as what we want.
Now all that being said Mike as a character has a very different opinion on what a jedi is/should be. He thinks more along the lines of "personal internal decision", a Jedi is the one who when faced with a decision chooses the one that is (to their experience) the "just" thing to do. He believes that to be a jedi is to serve the light in your own way, not in the way some old man (yes he is also an old man) at the top of the tower sitting in a circle tells you to. It's much more of an internal code rather than an external guild of justice seekers.
Just a few random opinions from a random person who showed up randomly.
|
|
|
Post by Vidalu Na'an on Oct 25, 2016 16:45:45 GMT -8
Huh. I don't know if my perspective means all that much here, seeing as my main character is someone that by any measure--hers, mine, or official--does NOT live up to the Jedi Code, as hard as she may try. But I'll try to summarize my view of the Jedi ideal in a few sentences.
In my mind, one of the first and foremost aspects of being a true Jedi is their connection to the Force--a mystical, nigh-holy power that flows throughout every living thing in the universe and may, in fact, be its own sentient thing (A god, maybe? Who knows but the dead?). This is achieved through meditation, training, and study of the texts handed down throughout generation to generation. A perfect connection can be seen as ascending to a higher state of being, and as a quasi-religious order, this search for ascension makes Jedi not unlike a sect of monks, either Catholic, Buddhist or otherwise. As such, any proper Jedi order must be willing to set aside any worldly concerns--wealth, power, influence, even relationships with others--if that is what is needed to achieve their higher goal. Granted, they may not always be ASKED to set such things aside, but if it is, there must be no hesitation. The Force first, above all other things.
That being said, the biggest way a Jedi can achieve this connection is through an iron control of the self. Again, this holds elements of self-denial common to any religious order--the body is weak, and the mind easily corrupted, and must be mastered in order for the spirit to progress. This is what separates the Jedi from the Sith, as the Sith believe that the impulses of the body and mind are powerful and should be indulged and manipulated. The Jedi believe that such passions cannot be manipulated--when they are indulged, they will manipulate YOU, ultimately to your doom. The body must be strong and well-maintained, not bent to weakness, indiscipline or anything as petty as addiction. The mind must be calm and clear, free of anxiety and fear and selfish desire. Both must be willing and able to withstand abuse in the name of a higher calling, as both are merely vessels of the Force within them.
Now, this kind of ascension leads to power--IMMENSE power. However, through their mastery of the body and mind's desires, a proper Jedi has eliminated any lust for such power, or the desire to exercise it through the domination of others. As a result, a Jedi should see his power as an opportunity to serve--to fight for those who cannot fight for themselves, to do what those in need cannot, to do whatever is asked of them by the Galaxy and its many peoples. While this service is often military, even more often it is not. Many Jedi who fail Knighthood stay in the Order as a member of the Service Corps, doing menial tasks across the galaxy, and even those who reach Knight or Master are called upon to use their wisdom for diplomatic purposes. As altruists and pacifists, the fight is a last resort, but one they are trained for.
tl;dr A true Jedi's primary goals are to achieve absolute control of himself, a perfect connection to the Force, and a life of servitude to those who need it.
|
|
|
Post by The Admiralty OOC on Oct 28, 2016 14:14:03 GMT -8
I'm sort of new to writing jedi's (& as of yet untrained) so this may change in time, but my views boil down to this.
OOC: Jedi are the keepers of peace. Sith, as the ultimate foes of peace are their main focus, but not their only one. For the most part, they are more like super cops than anything else & should hold themselves to the standard that position ideally represents. This doesn't exclude being married, owning stuff, or any number of other things, as long as it doesn't affect the work.
IC: Mary had a crash course in being a jedi from a holocron, though most of it was more geared toward surviving the short term future. She is more of a raging crusader. Criminals, Slavers, Sith. Doesn't matter, to her the appropriate sentence is death. No appeal, no mercy. On the other hand, anyone not in those groups she will go to extreme lengths to protect.
|
|
Sabo Alora
Member
Posts: 51
Affiliation: The Jedi Order
Traffic Light: Green
|
Post by Sabo Alora on Nov 7, 2016 6:33:25 GMT -8
I'll make this simple as can be. As an Order, we have left our galaxy boiling in Darkness for almost 10 years OOC. I know I haven't participated much in recent years, but it is not through a lack of trying. Most of the time we are standing around debating merits and negotiating terms , and I grow too bored.
Sabo is a very simple character to define, he is a grey jedi in everything but name. Emotions are useful when controlled, Passion can provide a drive to act, Chaos must be perceived as long as your mind is in a harmonious state, and there is no death, there is the force.
Now as far as our current role in the galaxy, I think I've pretty much summed it up already. I know with RP, that is is a difficult task to get everyone in a particular SL to agree and for the outcome to be decidedly in one groups favor. But it does seem like we spend too much time RPing a false sense of peace than actually combating tyranny in Our Galaxy.
This is only the view of a Casual RPer now, but most of you know that I once was very active in our community. Though I may not have a good grasp on the state of things right now, it doesn't seem like much of anything ever changes here. Especially where the Jedi Order is Concerned.
|
|